The love between a fish and an otter is given the thoughtful treatment such an unexpected attraction deserves… Howe explores the pleasure and pain of loving someone who is different from one’s self in a manner that is both sophisticated and accessible to children… Raschka’s childlike renderings of creatures in thick, penciled outlines create the innocence, mirror the hope and provide the universality that contributes to the title’s ascent above its purely message-driven counterparts. Ever-changing watercolor washes and primordial shapes depict a wondrous, liquid world in which the star-crossed lovers learn to trust their hearts.
—Kirkus Reviews (starred review)
Howe’s story reaches beyond its target audience and presents a lovely, unpreachy allegory for relationships that fall outside the mainstream.
—Publishers Weekly (starred review)
An unusual, inspiring tale of star-crossed lovers and nonconformity.
Howe’s narrative incorporates humor, earnest emotion, and a likable protagonist to convey important truths about following one’s heart and looking beyond the expectations of others. The text is lyrical and rhythmically cadenced, unfurling gracefully like a blossoming flower to reveal its wisdom. Resplendent in sparkling sun-warmed hues, Raschka’s watercolor-and-pencil illustrations use stick-figure-style characters and unembellished shapes to strike the perfect balance of simplicity and eloquence. Like Leo Lionni’s wonder-filled fables, this tale entertains while it inspires.–
—School Library Journal
This is a strong story of independence and choosing your own road in life.
—Library Media Connection
This strange and optimistic little fable is kin to Raschka’s Arlene Sardine (BCCB 9/98) and Willis’ Tadpole’s Promise (BCCB 7/05) in its cheerful, humorous weirdness, and the writing is prettily polished.
—Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books
Their love is so pure, I had tears in my eyes by the end. It’s beautiful—a story, a lesson of love that every child needs.
—The Atlantic Wire
James Howe expertly crafts this modern fable to be read on many levels. Although adults may read more into the muddied relationship, even young children will recognize the strength of staying true to oneself. Otter’s reflective tale gives hope and validity to love everywhere.
Together, Howe and Raschka movingly explore the complexities of who and how we love, where love found and where it takes us.
—New York Times online