Newman’s expressive drawings, done in a loose and economical style, serve the story well. His artwork, from the way he considers perspective, to the interesting and affective portrayals of the characters, allow readers (and parents!) to identify with this fiesty, yet sensitive, heroine…Nuanced and humorous, this is a worthy addition to the new-sibling shelf.
This story is part sibling rivalry and part bullying but it also features an interesting girl who chooses to play with earthmovers over dolls. The large bold paintings are perfect for storytime and are well used throughout to show mood and scale.
—School Library Journal
Readers will cheer for sloe-eyed Phoebe as she veers from mischievous grin to slow burn and back again, just as they will covet Digger, the most expressive steam shovel since Mike Mulligan’s Mary Anne.
Springstubb’s text is generously sprinkled with playful rhythms and dry, comradely drollery. Newman’s mixed-media art combines brisk horizontality with a sturdy retro flair in his figures and palette. He picks up the comic tone of the text and runs with it…Girls will appreciate a book that acknowledges their enjoyment of heavy machinery, and kids in general will warm to the joy of sublimating their frustration via measured destruction.
—Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books
Mixed-media illustrations in subdued hues, with sketchlike black lines and lots of white space, enhance the straightforward text while playing up the tale’s small moments and its big emotions. The story is notable for its sympathetic depictions of a rambunctious girl(!) truck lover (who is both the victim and perpetrator of teasing), her harried mother, and the not-always-adorable little baby; its relatable-to-new-big-siblings situations; and the nonsaccharine ending (bully-girl hasn’t learned her lesson, but Digger is on the case).
—The Horn Book
A breath of fresh air in the new sibling picture-book canon.
—Julie Danielson – Kirkus