A sweeping and epic novel…will someday be recognized as a novel of the first rank, the kind of monumental work Italo Calvino called ‘encyclopedic’ in the way it sweeps up history into a comprehensive and deeply textured pattern.
—New York Times Book Review
With an eye trained to the hypocrisies and conflicted loyalties of the American Revolution, Anderson resoundingly concludes the finely nuanced bildungsroman begun in his National Book Award–winning novel.
—Publishers Weekly (starred review)
Fascinating historical fiction…a thoughtful and timeless examination of the nature of humanity.
—School Library Journal (starred review)
Awe-inspiring…Even more present in this volume are passionate questions, directly relevant to teens’ lives, about basic human struggles for independence, identity, freedom, love, and the need to reconcile the past.
—Booklist (starred review)
—The Horn Book (starred review)
One of the few volumes to fully comprehend the paradoxes of the struggle for liberty in America.
—Kirkus Reviews (starred review)
Characters are lively and engaging with diverse personalities…a riveting book…Highly recommended.
—Library Media Connection, starred review
Octavian’s introspection born of a philosopher’s upbringing adds depth to the tale…a fast-moving plot…a satisfying finality to the story.
—Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books (starred review)
Places Octavian at the heart of…harrowing historical episodes underscoring the bleakness of a tale that is ultimately about the melancholy predicament of a brilliantly educated and appealing young black man in a world that has no place for him.
—Wall Street Journal
This deeply moving re-imagining of a little-known episode in American history should be required reading not only for high school students of the American Revolution, but, I would argue, for anyone who wants to see just what brilliance is possible in so-called children’s books.
It’s probably the best young-adult novel in American history, top 10 for sure.
A singular achievement, a work of historical fiction that feels truly original and seems destined to endure.
—San Francisco Chronicle
Open-ended, deliberately unclear about what happens next…the young man now seems to look within himself for the strength to live the rest of his life rather than looking toward one political side or the other. Readers end the stories awed by the overwhelming nature of the obstacles the characters face and by their persistent strength as survivors.
Anderson’s powerful and unforgettable novel is a vital contribution to the ongoing national conversation on the subject [slavery] and its effects on into the present day.
—Los Angeles Times
The riveting saga… poses questions about our nation’s hard-won liberty that are as illuminating as they are disturbing.
—St. Louis Post-Dispatch
The story continues to be a gripping one, unusual in offering a lens through which to see the Revolutionary War different from that to which Americans have been exposed — the views of a black man sympathetic, for the most part, to the king…It’s a truly courageous undertaking, ambitious in its scope in ways unparalleled by any other author working in this genre.
Surpasses long-awaited expectations…a remarkable conclusion to an unforgettable story.
—The Midwest Book Review
One of the best-written – and most challenging – young adult books I’ve ever read.
—The Millions blog