“Truly strange and truly wonderful” – The Observer, Best Books of 2018
“Deeply strange, incredibly fun sf/fantasy noir with artwork that pales only to that of McCay himself” – Library Journal
“A brain-bending book … peculiarly compelling” – SciFi Now
“Smolderen infuses McCay with a surreal, dreamlike plot … Bramanti’s art is stunning … An inspired book in every sense of the word” – Foreword Reviews
“Will hold you until the final page … Highly recommended” – Down The Tubes
“The dreamscapes with which Nemo and Fiend interact are rich and full” – The Comics Journal
“Smolderen and Bramanti’s McCay is the stuff that dreams are made of… and magically, much more” - Print Mag
“A captivating broad-strokes plot and fascinating small details … an accomplished piece of work, and one you can return to many times with equal fascination” – Multiversity Comics
“Full of weird ideas and a pretty keen plot, all wrapped around a compelling (if fictional) portrait of a brilliant cartoonist” – Atomic Junk
