The questions, discussion topics, and other material that follow are intended to enhance your group’s conversation of Hua Hsu’s Stay True: A Memoir,
a graceful and moving narrative in which the author shares about his youth in California as the son of Taiwanese immigrants, his struggles to find a like-minded community growing up, his relationship with music, and the college years that shaped his search for self in the wake of a friend’s sudden and violent death.
Questions and Topics for Discussion
1. Discuss the narrator’s relationship with his parents, who are at times far away. How would you describe the Hsu family dynamic?
2. The memoir is set mainly in suburban California during the 1980s and 1990s. How does the time period and location shape Hua’s experience of growing up? How does it mirror or contrast with your understanding of those decades?
3. Music is a prominent element in Hua’s life throughout the book, influencing both how he sees himself and how he judges others. How does the music he listens to relate to or reflect the events in his life, from childhood to college years? How does he change or incorporate other ways of engaging with society over the course of the narrative?
4. The creation of original zines is Hua’s ongoing focus during his college years. How does his creative process evolve across the narrative, and what does the zine represent at each stage of his life?
5. The book explores class and generational differences in identifying with the Asian American label. Hua suspects that Ken’s sense of confidence comes from the fact that his Japanese American family is more assimilated than Hua’s Taiwanese American one is. Did this impact the way you think about cultural differences and Asian communities in America? If so, how?
6. Compare and contrast Hua and Ken’s tastes in pop culture, their approaches to life, and their ultimate fate in the book. What do you make of this unlikely friendship? How does their relationship deepen over time, and how did they end up influencing each other’s lives?
7. Hua explores his friendships and relationships via the lens of Marcel Mauss’s social theory of reciprocity and gift exchange, in which a practice of gift giving is proposed as an alternative to the economic individual and capitalism. What benefits, if any, does a system of reciprocity provide to individuals and communities? What “lost world” (page 105) might be salvaged through a spirit of gift giving?
8. Stay True is driven by the author’s desire to remember his friend and reconcile with a senseless loss. Discuss how Hua’s attitude toward Ken’s death changes over time, and what his final reflections on the person he has become suggest about Hua’s connection to grief, nostalgia, and living.
9. How would you describe the support Hua receives from his friends, peers, parents, and counselors? How effective were they in helping him make sense of a tragedy?
10. Have you ever experienced a sudden, shocking loss yourself or through someone you know? To which events in the memoir were you most able to relate? How would you choose to remember loved ones who have departed?
11. As a teenager, Hua is preoccupied with projecting an image of “cool” and crafting a voice and a place for himself in the world. He broods on the idea of authenticity and the promise to “stay true.” What does it mean for Hua to “stay true,” and why did he choose this as the title for his memoir? What is authenticity to you?
by Zadie Smith So Many Olympic Exertions
by Anelise Chen Illegally Yours: A Memoir
by Rafael AgustinOn Earth We’re Briefly Gorgeous
by Ocean Vuong Minor Feelings: An Asian American Reckoning
by Cathy Park Hong