Praise for The Murder of Mr. Ma
Winner of the Anthony Award for Best Historical Novel
Winner of the CALA Best Book Award for Adult Fiction
Shortlisted for the 2025 ALA Reading List for Mystery Fiction
Nominated for the Anthony Award for Best Historical Novel
NPR’s Books We Love 2024
Named a Best Mystery Book of the Year by Parade, Library Journal, and the South Florida Sun Sentinel
An Amazon Editors’ Pick for Best Mystery Book of the Month
“A glorious mash up of fan fiction (with tips of the hat to Robert van Gulik and Arthur Conan Doyle), kung fu prowess (Dee could easily star in a martial arts movie) and droll social commentary (‘The British,’ Dee remarks early on, ‘are oddly vulnerable to charm’).”
—The New York Times Book Review
“The vivid action scenes feel as visceral as a Chow Yun-fat circular kick with double forearm strike. A sparkling and thought-provoking debut of a fresh dynamic duo whose adventures I’ll be eager to follow.”
—Paula Woods, Los Angeles Times
“Co-authors Nee and Rozan offer an appealingly unusual, action-packed Sherlock Holmes pastiche with deep roots in both Chinese crime fiction and the history of early 20th-century England.”
—The Washington Post
“[A] blast of fun . . . The action is as furious as the thinking—this is no staid, sit at home and ponder the evidence storyline. The writing duo of John Shen Yen Nee and SJ Rozan make a great team, too.”
—Parade
“Amid the whirl of crescent kicks, rooftop chases, and snappy dialogue, characters confront addiction, defy prejudice, and deliver justice. It’s a cinematic ride.”
—The Christian Science Monitor
“It’s a bit murder mystery, a bit martial arts action movie and a bit historical drama; think Warrior meets Sherlock Holmes.”
—NPR.org
“A clever homage to Holmes . . . [Rozan & Nee] have launched a highly entertaining new series with The Murder of Mr. Ma.”
—Oline Cogdill, South Florida Sun Sentinel
“The Murder of Mr. Ma is a refreshingly unique mystery featuring a Chinese detective and his somewhat unwitting partner in 1920s London, combining classic elements from both British and Chinese detective stories in a thrilling romp that doesn’t shy away from the realities of life under colonial dynamics. Lao She and Dee Ren Jie are a hilarious and compelling duo to follow!”
—Xiran Jay Zhao, #1 New York Times bestselling author of Iron Widow
“The Murder of Mr. Ma is a joy, with this Chinese Sherlock Holmes and his Watson bringing a thrilling, complex, and thought-provoking new take on 1920s London.”
—Laurie R. King, bestselling author of The Lantern’s Dance
“Fans of Sherlock Holmes, devotees of intricate crime, and lovers of historical London will thrill over The Murder of Mr. Ma, the new gift to mystery readers bestowed by John Shen Yen Nee and SJ Rozan. With a plot as clever as Chinese veteran of WWI turned independent investigator Dee, and pacing as light-footed as the martial artists engaged in the frequent fisticuffs, this case has it all—even romance and authentic food, if you can stomach such things. I’m only miffed because I don’t know when the next in the series will land on my doorstep.”
—Lyndsay Faye, author of Dust and Shadow
“A rollicking, page turning novel filled with wonderful characters (some of whom, like the novel’s two protagonists, are based on actual historical figures), edge of your seat action and a challenging mystery . . . Readers will be ready for the sequel the moment they turn the last page.”
—Los Angeles Public Library, Staff Recommendation
“I was blown away by this exuberant, fun, cinematic tale of two Chinese immigrants—kung-fu fighting Judge Dee and his unlikely sidekick, academic Lao She—making like Holmes and Watson in the mean streets of 1920’s London.”
—Vannessa Cronin, Amazon Editors’ Pick
“Mash-ups, genre-benders, unexpected fusion . . . I like mystery books that bring something new to the same old game, and, this time, the game is afoot wearing an entirely different shoe. The Murder of Mr. Ma is a rollicking, fast-paced adventure that weaves the grand tradition of a Sherlock Holmesan homage into traditional Chinese gong’an crime fiction with explosive results . . . Anyone with a need for a quick read that keeps you on your toes will love this one.”
—Des Moines Cityview
“A diverting and fresh combination of a whodunnit with a swashbuckling romp through London’s Chinese communities in the 1920s . . . [The authors’] literary influences are proudly on display: the Sherlock Holmes stories and the British penny dreadfuls of the 19th century, alongside the 16th and 17th century ‘crime-case’ fiction of China. There’s more than a hint of the earliest adventures of The Batman, too.”
—Morning Star
“The team-up of the great detective Judge Dee with Lao as his ‘Watson’ is ingenious.”
—Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine
“From rooftops to back alleys, the book offers insights into British class at the time, postwar changes in culture, and anti-Chinese sentiment and maneuvers, seasoned with lively adventures and abundant humor.”
—Historical Novels Review
“The compelling plot moves along swiftly. Further, it’s filled with booby-trapped buildings, masterful disguises (including Springheel Jack), the click of mah-jongg tiles, and the awful prejudice that pervaded the times in which the novel is set. Forget the time anomaly: take a journey back a hundred years with a 1,300-year-old character. You won’t regret it.”
—Deadly Pleasures Mystery Magazine
“A fun read, with a well-plotted mystery and unbelievably choreographed kung fu scenes. As a lifelong Sherlock Holmes fan . . . I’ve read a number of retellings over the years. This one ranks right up there with the Lady Charlotte series as one of my favorites.”
—Elizabeth Held, What To Read If
“Jump into this absurd and charming period mystery for the wild scenes of threat, battle, rescue, and humor, and make the most of the fun involved.”
—New York Journal of Books
“Unique and special . . . Rozan and Nee will educate readers as they entertain them . . . Fans—and you will be a fan—can look forward to the next adventure that blends logical investigation with kick-ass action in a way that crime fiction readers rarely encounter.”
—BOLO Books
“A superb action adventure mystery.”
—Gumshoe Review
“Fans of Sherlock Holmes will recognize the format, a brilliant, addicted sleuth accompanied by an admiring assistant. But, the authors put their own spin on it as the two men are Chinese, trying to help their fellow Chinese in a London that sees them as lesser beings. The Murder of Mr. Ma is unrelenting in its pace, a wonderful tale of adventure and derring-do.”
—Lesa’s Book Critiques
“A bewitching series kickoff . . . The intricate plot, which is bolstered by vivid period detail and playfully riffs on real-life figures in Chinese history (including Lao), is enhanced by healthy doses of humor and well-orchestrated action. Readers will be clamoring for a sequel.”
—Publishers Weekly, Starred Review
“Rozan and comics exec Nee create a distinct sense of time and place in this brisk adventure . . . Lao narrates their adventures as Dee impersonates a street legend, ‘Springheel Jack, the Terror of London,’ swinging from lampposts and launching himself across rooftops in search of a killer. Fans of the Sherlock Holmes canon will appreciate this fast-paced, exciting novel.”
—Library Journal, Starred Review
“Probably the best homage to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s iconic pairing of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. John Watson . . . The Murder of Mr. Ma is a masterpiece.”
—BookTrib
“A high-energy, rambunctious tale . . . The authors do a wonderful job of depicting the bustling London of the ‘20s, the Chinese community and the relentless racism and stereotypes it is a victim of, and absolutely fabulous displays of martial arts. There’s word that Dr. Dee may be returning to solve another case; here’s hoping he does!”
—First Clue Reviews
“Judge Dee, though fighting his addiction to opium, manages to come up with a plausible reason why so many members of the battalion have met sudden deaths and to excel in the bouts of martial arts in which so many scenes of conflict end . . . First of a series that’s acutely attuned to British racism between the two world wars.”
—Kirkus Reviews
“The plot is extremely clever, and for much of it, we are led astray by cunningly placed red herrings. But the clues are there, and the final unveiling of the villain is perfectly planned and executed . . . Perhaps the best part is that we know there will be more mysteries to solve with these two intriguing characters.”
—Bookreporter
QUICK VIEW
