“Wonderfully wry-melancholy…. An auspicious and stirring debut.” —The New York Times
This Reading Group Guide*—consisting of an introduction, discussion questions, suggestions for further reading, and biography—is designed to enhance your group’s discussion of A Brief History of the Flood
Lillian Anderson is a strong-minded, backwoods-Minnesota girl, well-versed in the basics of survival. She can find air to breathe under a capsized boat, drive in a blizzard, or capture a wild duck. As part of a large struggling family, she tiptoes around her explosive father whose best days always come right after he’s poached something and her neurotically optimistic mother whose bursts of vigor bring added chaos. Lillian barrels through adolescence with no illusions about her future, honing her clerical skills while working the nightshift as a salad girl in the airport kitchen. Just as she’s on her feet and moving out, their house is literally sinking into the marsh. Stunningly honest, this story explores the fierce love that binds family together.
Questions and Topics for Discussion
1. As the book opens, Lillian’s mother, Marion, looks around the breakfast table at her husband and children and says, “Now this is how it’s supposed to be” [p. 3]. What does she mean? What does the author want the reader to understand from this comment?
2. Marion creates a surprising pontoon-boat float for her family to ride on in the Acorn Lake Fourth of July boat parade. Its theme might be viewed as a baseline for eight-year-old Lillian’s ideas about what life is supposed to be like. What events force her to reconsider? If Lillian, as an adult, were to construct a pontoon-boat float symbolizing her own idea of happiness, what theme might she choose?
3. Some families seem to be held together by the glue of secrets. What secrets do the Andersons keep? Why? Would those same secrets be kept in a family today?
4. What is the significance of the girls who work the nightshift making salads for airline flights? How do they add to our understanding of Lillian’s life? Of Marion’s? Are they merely relics of a time gone by, or are they still relevant today?
5. Lillian says about her best friend, Irene, “Once you reach homecoming queen, there’s no place else to go but bad” [p. 159]. What does this statement say about small towns? About opportunities for girls?
6. Little violence takes place in the Anderson household, yet Lillian’s father, Jack, has a talent for making the entire family feel as if they’re living under a clenched fist. How is this tension created and maintained? What makes this tension tolerable to Lillian? To the reader?
7. Is Lillian a reliable narrator? Does she ever lie to the reader, or to herself?
8. The title comes from a letter Marion writes to the IRS. Why do you think the author chose this title? What might you have called it?
9. Lillian says, “I don’t want anybody ever looking at me like the girl who got her ducks shot” [p. 57]. What does this statement reveal about her character? Do any of the other family members share this sentiment?
10. Lillian says of her best friend, Irene, “Nothing you can say will shock her” [p. 107], and she notes that Irene “can sweep a room clean of guilt, doesn’t matter who owns it or how they earned it. Usually that’s what you want in a friend” [p. 105]. What does Irene offer Lillian that she can’t get from other relationships? In what ways does Irene resemble Lillian’s mother? How are they different?
11. Why doesn’t Marion seem to see Jack’s failings as a husband and father?
12. How are Lillian’s actions in “Duck Season” a continuation of what took place in “Body Count?”
13. What role does shame play in the Andersons’ behavior? What are its sources? Which children are most affected by it? Why? How does it influence their choices?
14. Men generally aren’t portrayed here in a positive light. What type of men do you think Randy and Davey will become? Why?
15. At the end of the book how does each member of the Anderson family think “it’s supposed to be” [p. 3]?
About this Author
This is Jean Harfenist’s first book. It was a Minneapolis Star Tribune
Best Book of the Year. Stories excerpted from it won the Prism International Fiction Prize and received special mention for The Pushcart Prize. She was named a finalist for the Katherine Anne Porter Nimrod/Hartman Award, the Kirkwood Literary Prize, the Missouri Review Editor’s Prize, and the Indiana Review Fiction Prize. Her short stories have appeared in The Missouri Review
, The Barcelona Review
, Quarterly West
, Sycamore Review
, Sonora Review
, Wisconsin Review
, The Sun
and the Cream City Review
. She is a native of Minnesota, a graduate of New York University, and now lives in Santa Barbara with her husband.
* Discussion questions written by the author.
Mona Simpson, Anywhere but Here
; Mary Karr, The Liar’s Club: A Memoir
; Tobias Wolff, This Boy’s Life
; Richard Russo, Empire Falls
; Kaye Gibbons, Ellen Foster;
Louise Erdrich, Love Medicine;
, Annie Proulx, The Shipping News
; Ann Tyler, Dinner at the Homesick Restaurant
; Jane Smiley, A Thousand Acres
; Dorothy Allison, Bastard Out of Carolina
; Susan Minot, Monkeys
; Alexandra Fuller, Don’t Let’s Go to the Dogs Tonight
; Marilynne Robinson, Housekeeping
; Carol Shields, The Stone Diaries
; Harper Lee, To Kill a Mockingbird
; Mark Twain, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn