In the narrative, Hest doesn’t spell out everything that’s happening, instead leaving some things unspoken for the readers and listeners’ imaginations to interpret. At first glance, this volume might resemble a wordless picture book, given how detailed and evocative Thornock’s softly colored illustrations are. . . . The glorious, original artwork and empowering story of the simple pleasures of baking and sharing combine into a delectable tale of intergenerational affection and fun.
—Booklist (starred review)
Like a handwoven lattice crust, this finely worked story by Hest (Bunny Should Be Sleeping) and Thornock (Brave Old Blue) embodies the fruits of painstaking attention. . . . Small in scale yet large in feeling, this unhurried, gently stepwise telling exudes the care that it celebrates.
—Publishers Weekly
A delectable, deeply felt invitation to see that when it comes to pie, the making and sharing is as rewarding as the eating.
—School Library Journal
A homey and original take on the selfless-deed story.
—Kirkus Reviews
Readers can think of this quiet adventure as a non-saccharine pep talk for the younger set, where the poetic language and constant second-person repetition of “you” remind kiddos that they can do hard things and find fulfillment in doing them. . . . Thornock’s digital illustrations are pencil-like, filled in with pastel colors and creating a visual softness that matches the language, which reads like a lullaby even as it describes a rather exciting day.
—Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books