An Amazon Best Book of the Month
“The novel’s remote setting gives the story a timeless quality . . . There are echoes of the Odyssey, but there’s also the very real ruggedness and danger of the New England landscape—something that can get lost in today’s highly aestheticized, social media version of the region.” —Samara Brass, The Portland Press Herald
“In this lush debut, Smith does a deft job of exploring the tug of war between familial loyalty and self-interest—digging into what it is to be human.” —Amazon
“A beautiful debut.” —Emily Burack, Town and Country
“From the opening pages of The Shared Life of Egan and Lucian, there’s tension stirring in the ocean breezes. Rose Smith’s debut novel sets a nautical scene for domestic intrigue and a slow untangling of these inseparable brothers fated to share their existence . . . Life in these pages moves with aching detail at times, bodies and faces shifting subtly and precisely in closely observed detail . . . Smith’s previous work in film is as palpable in these opposing but equally striking storytelling modes as it is in her attention to the landscapes and objects of Egan and Lucian’s world. Shep’s Island teems with picturesque life.” —Caroline Drew, The Austin Chronicle
“A warm novel for those who need it. Reading it truly felt like sitting on the beach, wrapped in a blanket, as the summer fades away and the welcome chill of the changing season overtakes you. Rose Smith is a wonder.” —Adam Vitcavage, Debutiful
“In her stunning debut novel, Smith adeptly navigates the complex, intertwined relationships of the twins, their families biological and found, and their insular island community. The lyrical prose and strong sense of place will appeal to fans of Claire Lombardo’s The Most Fun We Ever Had and Louise Kennedy’s Stations.” —Booklist (starred review)
“A luminous debut . . . The author shines in her complex depictions of the characters’ relationships and their double lives . . . It’s a heartrending exploration of passion and the various forms love can take.” —Publishers Weekly (starred review)
“The sense of place is strong, and the settings feel cinematic, especially the primary setting on a fictional island off the coast of Maine . . . This confidently written, atmospheric debut novel from Smith wrestles with the tension between familial duty and personal desire.” —Library Journal
“Smith’s debut has much to recommend, particularly the beautifully evoked settings, not just the island but also Buenos Aires and, briefly, New York, as well as the detailed descriptions of artistic process . . . Bad blood between brothers drives a dramatic plot grounded by a strong sense of place. A promising debut.” —Kirkus Reviews
“What a lovely, captivating novel! Rose Smith smoothly navigates a memorable story of twin brothers and the woman who loves them both. Her prose is luscious, and she has much to show us about love and art and parenthood and so much else. And I don’t think I’ve ever read a more affecting description of Maine’s everchanging and often devastating landscape. Brava.” —Monica Wood, author of How to Read a Book
“The Shared Life of Egan and Lucian doesn’t read like a debut novel, but that—somehow—is what it is. Characters as vividly real as your neighbors? An unforgettable setting? A propulsive plot? They’re all here, and Rose Smith is a writer to watch.” —Richard Russo, author of Empire Falls and the North Bath Fool novels
“With graceful prose and an attentive eye for the complexities and contradictions of love, Rose Smith has fashioned a saga of family romance and betrayal that held me in its grip from its opening sentence through to its bracing end.” —Marisa Silver, author of At Last
“Atmospheric and quietly powerful, The Shared Life of Egan and Lucian explores twinship, love, and identity on a Maine island where memory and rivalry bind two lives. A striking debut about family—what holds, what loosens, and what we cannot leave behind.” —Adrienne Brodeur, author of Little Monsters
“The Shared Life of Egan and Lucian is a celebration of both an extraordinary family and the way the intensities of some of our most passionate bonds can weather any number of demoralizing secrets and betrayals. It’s also masterful on the way that that same fierce focus can blind even the most self-aware. Rose Smith’s debut is an arresting and lyrical reminder of all there is to cherish and how quickly it can all go away.” —Jim Shepard, author of The Queen of Bad Influences