* “In Saeed’s latest, readers meet a sharp, determined Pakistani girl whose dream of becoming a doctor runs up against family expectations, gender norms, and structural barriers that feel culturally specific and universally recognizable. . . . Saeed excels at portraying the quiet, everyday negotiations girls make in pursuit of autonomy without flattening any character into a villain or hero. Hafsa’s persistence is grounded not in defiance for its own sake but in an ethical clarity. . . . She learns that standing up for what’s right often comes with consequences and that growth is rarely linear or comfortable. The intergenerational dynamics, particularly among women, are rendered with nuance and care, highlighting both constraint and solidarity across urban and rural Pakistan. . . . Will resonate deeply with middle grade readers, especially those negotiating identity, ambition, and belonging. It also offers rich opportunities for classroom discussion around gender equity, cultural expectations, moral courage, and advocacy. A compelling, justice-centered middle grade novel that refuses to oversimplify courage or coming-of-age and a powerful reminder that finding one’s voice is rarely easy but always worth the risk.” —School Library Journal, starred review
“This companion to Amal Unbound and Omar Rising highlights challenges that girls face in traditional households. Hafsa’s persistence and advocacy help her overcome her insecurities, and meaningful interactions create moments of introspection and understanding. Inspired by a real-life story from the Islamabad Zoo, this is a timely story. . . . Effectively blends climate change, wildlife conservation, and the tug of cultural expectations. An inspiring story showing the power of one person’s voice to make a difference.” —Kirkus Reviews
“Through Hafsa, Saeed artfully illustrates the challenges of trying to meet familial expectations while also forging one’s own path and making the most of life in an ever-changing world. . . . Hafsa’s desire to help both herself and others succeed is inspiring. This standalone companion to Amal Unbound will satisfy Saeed’s existing fans and entice newcomers to her work.” —Booklist
“[Hafsa’s] disappointment soon grows into curiosity and concern for the animals in the city zoo and their deteriorating living conditions—especially for elephant, Gulab. Hafsa’s deepening attachment to Gulab and her activism against animal cruelty steadily unfolds. . . . The development of Hafsa’s passions evolves naturally and credibly, and her achievements feel well-earned.” —Publishers Weekly
“Tweens will admire how [Hafsa] builds on her individual experiences to fight for something more than just herself. Whether dealing with bullies, convincing her sister to follow her own dreams, starting a campaign to send the elephant to a sanctuary, or studying hard . . . Hafsa learns when to rock the boat and when to allow other people to want different things than she does.” —The Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books
QUICK VIEW
