“The strips [are] gorgeously composed, with characters dancing elegantly on the page…. [A] playfully wry and tender portrait of married life among the social set.” —Françoise Mouly, The New Yorker
“The invaluable Irvin, artist, ex-actor, wit, and sophisticate about town and country, did more to develop the style and excellence of New Yorker drawings and covers than anyone else.” —James Thurber
“The strip was a domestic comedy; a husband and wife navigating the brittle charms and absurdities of upper-middle-class life. But under Irvin’s pen, the couple became something more than a gag. They were a mirror, lightly fogged with irony, reflecting the anxieties and aspirations of postwar America . . .To read Rea Irvin’s The Smythes now is to rediscover not only his forgotten brilliance but a quieter kind of humor, one that trusts its reader to see the joke without being told when to laugh. It’s a reminder that irony and tenderness, in the right hands, are not opposites at all.” —Tammi Morton-Kelly, The Comics Journal