Skip to Main Content (Press Enter) Toggle side nav

Spoiled Reader’s Guide

By Caitlin Macy

Spoiled by Caitlin Macy


Questions and Topics for Discussion

1. In two of the stories, “Annabel’s Mother” and “The Red Coat,” Macy writes about a woman’s conflicted relationship with her domestic help—a nanny and a cleaning woman, respectively. What do you think a woman’s relationship with her help says about her as a person?

2. In “The Secret Vote,” a young woman raised Roman Catholic reacts with distaste to the idea of a gay couple having a child with a surrogate mother. But the story ends with the young woman herself having an abortion. What is Macy saying about the woman’s perspective? Is it hypocritical?

3. Unlike the United Kingdom, America isn’t supposed to have true class distinctions, yet these nuances play an important role in Spoiled. Why do you think that is?

4. Are there moral lessons that can be taken from the ways the women in these stories behave? Do you think these stories are meant to be cautionary tales?

5. The women in most of these stories are well-off, some of them very well-off. Why do you think they aren’t happier?

6. The subjects of several of the stories (“Annabel’s Mother,” “Bad Ghost,” “Spoiled,” “Bait and Switch”) are parents and their children, or parental stand-ins—nannies, friends’ mothers, a girl’s riding instructor—and their charges. Do you think a spoiled child makes for a spoiled adult?

7. This book came out in the middle of a global financial meltdown. How do you think the characters would be doing in today’s financial climate?

8. What does it mean to be spoiled?

Back to Top